ThreeDimensionalConfigurations/ChallengesPt3

From jetwiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Challenges Constructing Ellipsoidal-Like Configurations (Pt. 3)

This chapter extends the accompanying chapters titled, Construction Challenges (Pt. 1) and (Pt. 2). The focus here is on firming up our understanding of the relationships between various "tilted" Cartesian coordinate frames.

Various Coordinate Frames

Riemann-Derived Expressions

Inertial Frame (green with subscript "0")
and Body Frame (black and unsubscripted).

Inertial and Body Frames

For our chosen Example Type I Ellipsoid, we have, Ω2=0.3639 and Ω3=0.6633, in which case, Ω0=0.7566 and δ=0.5018rad=28.75.

The purple (ellipsoidal) configuration is spinning with frequency, Ω0 about the z0-axis of the "inertial frame," as illustrated; that is,

Ω

=

k^0Ω0.

Also as illustrated, the "body frame," which is attached to and aligned with the principal axes of the purple ellipsoid, is tilted at an angle, δ, with respect to the inertial frame. Hence, as viewed from the body frame, we have,

Ω

=

[ȷ^sinδ+k^cosδ]Ω0.

Now, adhering to the notation used by [EFE] — see, for example, the first paragraph of §51 (p. 156) — we should write,

Ω

=

ȷ^Ω2+k^Ω3Ω2=Ω0sinδ    and,     Ω3=Ω0cosδ.

This means that,

Ω0

=

[Ω22+Ω32]1/2    and,     δ=tan1[Ω2Ω3].

As we have summarized in an accompanying discussion of Riemann Type 1 ellipsoids, [EFE] provides an expression for the velocity vector of each fluid element, given its instantaneous body-coordinate position (x, y, z) = (x1, x2, x3) — see his Eq. (154), Chapter 7, §51 (p. 156). As viewed from the rotating frame of reference, the three component expressions are,

x˙=u1=ı^u

=

(ab)2γΩ3y(ac)2βΩ2z

=

[a2a2+b2]ζ3y+[a2a2+c2]ζ2z,

y˙=u2=ȷ^u

=

γΩ3x

=

+[b2a2+b2]ζ3x,

z˙=u3=k^u

=

+βΩ2x

=

[c2a2+c2]ζ2x,

where,

β

=

[c2a2+c2]ζ2Ω2

      and,      

γ

=

[b2a2+b2]ζ3Ω3.

Rotating-Frame Vorticity

ζ×𝐮

=

ı^[z˙yy˙z]+ȷ^[x˙zz˙x]+k^[y˙xx˙y]

 

=

ȷ^{[a2a2+c2]ζ2+[c2a2+c2]ζ2}+k^{[b2a2+b2]ζ3+[a2a2+b2]ζ3}

 

=

ȷ^ζ2+k^ζ3.

For our chosen Example Type I Ellipsoid, we have, ζ2=2.2794 and Ω3=1.9637, in which case, ζrot=(ζ22+ζ32)1/2=2.2794 and ξtan1[ζ2/ζ3]=4.0013rad=229.26.

Vorticity Axis
Vorticity Axis

Tipped Orbit Planes

Summary

In a separate discussion, we have shown that, as viewed from a frame that "tumbles" with the (purple) body of a Type 1 Riemann ellipsoid, each Lagrangian fluid element moves along an elliptical path in a plane that is tipped by an angle θ about the x-axis of the body. As viewed from the (primed) coordinates associated with this tipped plane, by definition, z' = constant and dz'/dt = 0, and the planar orbit is defined by the expression for an,

Off-Center Ellipse

1

=

[xxmax]2+[yyc(z)ymax]2.

Tipped Orbit Frame (yellow, primed)

Tipped Orbital Planes

Given that b/a = 1.25 and c/a = 0.4703 for our chosen Example Type I Ellipsoid, we find that, θ=0.3320rad=19.02.

Notice that the offset, yc, is a function of the tipped plane's vertical coordinate, z. As a function of time, the x'-y' coordinates and associated velocity components of each Lagrangian fluid element are given by the expressions,

x

=

xmaxcos(φ˙t)

      and,      

yyc

=

ymaxsin(φ˙t),

x˙

=

xmaxφ˙sin(φ˙t)=(ycy)[xmaxymax]φ˙

      and,      

y˙

=

ymaxφ˙cos(φ˙t)=x[ymaxxmax]φ˙.

As has been summarized in an accompanying discussion, we have determined that (numerical value given for our chosen example Type I ellipsoid),

tanθ

=

ζ2ζ3[a2+b2a2+c2]c2b2=βΩ2γΩ3=0.34479,

where, β and γ are as defined above. Also,

[xmaxymax]2

=

a2b2c2(c2cos2θ+b2sin2θ)=1.05238,

φ˙2

=

ζ32[b2a2+b2]2[xmaxymax]2[1+tan2θ]=1.68818,

yc

=

+zb2tanθc2cos2θ+b2sin2θ=+ztanθ[ymaxxmax]2a2c2=(zcosθ)(1.40038).

Note that this last expression has been obtained by making the substitutions, y0yc and z0z/cosθ, in the accompanying derivation's expression for y0.

Demonstration

In order to transform a vector from the "tipped orbit" frame (primed coordinates) to the "body" frame (unprimed), we use the following mappings of the three unit vectors:

ı^

ı^,

ȷ^

ȷ^cosθ+k^sinθ,

k^

ȷ^sinθ+k^cosθ.

Given that, by design in our "tipped orbit" frame, there is no vertical motion — that is, z˙=0 — mapping the (primed coordinate) velocity to the body (unprimed) coordinate is particularly straightforward. Specifically,

u

=

ı^x˙+ȷ^y˙

 

ı^x˙+[ȷ^cosθ+k^sinθ]y˙

 

=

ı^{(ycy)(xmaxymax)φ˙}+[ȷ^cosθ+k^sinθ]{x(ymaxxmax)φ˙}.

Recognizing, as before, that the relevant coordinate mapping is,

x

x,

y

ycosθ+zsinθ,

z

zcosθysinθ,

we have,

u

ı^φ˙(xmaxymax){ycycosθzsinθ}+ȷ^φ˙(ymaxxmax){xcosθ}+k^φ˙(ymaxxmax){xsinθ},

where,

yc

+[zcosθysinθ]tanθ[ymaxxmax]2a2c2.

Written in terms of the "body" frame coordinates, therefore, the 2nd and 3rd components of this velocity vector are, respectively:

ȷ^u

=

xφ˙(ymaxxmax)cosθ

 

=

x{ζ32[b2a2+b2]2[xmaxymax]2[1+tan2θ]}1/2(ymaxxmax)cosθ

 

=

x{ζ3[b2a2+b2]},

k^u

=

xφ˙(ymaxxmax)sinθ

 

=

x{ζ32[b2a2+b2]2[xmaxymax]2[1+tan2θ]}1/2(ymaxxmax)sinθ

 

=

x{ζ3[b2a2+b2]}tanθ

 

=

x{ζ3[b2a2+b2]}{ζ2ζ3[a2+b2a2+c2]c2b2}

 

=

x{ζ2[c2a2+c2]}.

These expressions perfectly match the body-coordinate expressions derived by Riemann (see above) for, respectively, y˙ and z˙. The 1st component is,

ı^u

=

φ˙(xmaxymax){ycycosθzsinθ}

 

=

{ζ32[b2a2+b2]2[xmaxymax]2[1+tan2θ]}1/2(xmaxymax){ycycosθzsinθ}

 

=

ζ3[b2a2+b2](xmaxymax)2{yccosθyztanθ}

 

=

(xmaxymax)2{ζ3[b2a2+b2]yccosθyζ3[b2a2+b2]+zζ3[b2a2+b2]ζ2ζ3[a2+b2a2+c2]c2b2}

 

=

(xmaxymax)2{ζ3[b2a2+b2]yccosθyζ3[a2a2+b2]b2a2+zζ2[a2a2+c2]c2a2}.

So, implementing the mapping of yc, the first term inside the curly braces becomes,

ζ3[b2a2+b2]yccosθ

ζ3cosθ[b2a2+b2]{+[zcosθysinθ]tanθ[ymaxxmax]2a2c2}

 

=

ζ3[b2a2+b2][ymaxxmax]2a2c2{ytan2θ}+ζ3[b2a2+b2]tanθ[ymaxxmax]2a2c2{z}

 

=

yζ3[b2a2+b2][ymaxxmax]2a2c2{tan2θ}zζ2[c2a2+c2][ymaxxmax]2a2c2{tan2θ}

(xmaxymax)2ζ3[b2a2+b2]yccosθ

yζ3[b2a2+b2]a2c2{tan2θ}zζ2[c2a2+c2]a2c2{tan2θ}

[xmaxymax]2=a2b2c2(c2cos2θ+b2sin2θ)

[xmaxymax]2[1+tan2θ]=a2b2c2(c2+b2tan2θ)

Therefore,

ı^u

=

yζ3[b2a2+b2]a2c2{tan2θ}zζ2[c2a2+c2]a2c2{tan2θ}+{zζ2[c2a2+c2]yζ3[b2a2+b2]}(xmaxymax)2

 

=

yζ3[b2a2+b2]a2c2{tan2θ}yζ3[b2a2+b2](xmaxymax)2+zζ2[c2a2+c2](xmaxymax)2zζ2[c2a2+c2]a2c2{tan2θ}

 

=

yζ3[a2a2+b2]{b2c2tan2θ+b2a2(xmaxymax)2}+zζ2[c2a2+c2]{(xmaxymax)2a2c2tan2θ}

 

=

yζ3[a2a2+b2]{b2c2tan2θ+1c2(c2cos2θ+b2sin2θ)}+zζ2[c2a2+c2]{a2b2c2(c2cos2θ+b2sin2θ)a2c2tan2θ}

 

=

yζ3[a2a2+b2]1c2cos2θ{b2sin2θ+(c2cos2θ+b2sin2θ)cos2θ}+zζ2[c2a2+c2]{a2b2c2(c2cos2θ+b2sin2θ)a2c2tan2θ}

See Also

  • Related discussions of models viewed from a rotating reference frame:


Tiled Menu

Appendices: | VisTrailsEquations | VisTrailsVariables | References | Ramblings | VisTrailsImages | myphys.lsu | ADS |